Political violence in West Bengal needs the SC as well as EC's attention?


Political violence in West Bengal needs the SC as well as EC's attention?

West Bengal is attracting a lot of attention these days because of multiple communal riots since October 2016. Besides communal disturbance, the state is also witnessing political violence between TMC and BJP workers.

Since the arrest of TMC's two Lok Sabha MPs in connection with chit fund scams, Mamata Banerjee's party workers have allegedly attacked BJP office bearers and destroyed their offices in various parts of the state.

BJP's WB state headquarters in Kolkata was attacked on Tuesday, January 3 and on the next day, party's Hooghly office was set on fire allegedly by TMC workers. State's police stood like mute spectators and CRPF had to take charge of the situation.

According to a report published by Times of India, a bomb was hurled at BJP leader Krishna Bhattacharya's house by TMC workers and she had to be hospitalized due to injuries. Even Babul Supriyo's parents were targeted.

Bharatiya Janata Party's West Bengal unit has demanded the state's governor to impose president's rule due to the failure of law and order.

Reaction from political leaders

If the leaders have not done anything wrong and if they have enough evidence against others, why can't they spell it out to the CBI and prove their innocence? The onus is on the prosecution to prove the guilt in the court. If no guilt is proven, the TMC will emerge as champion.

Several prominent politicians, including country's former Prime Minister H D Deve Gowda, reacted to this by saying that TMC should fight this battle legally and not on streets.

While reacting on the lawlessness in West Bengal, BJP's Rajya Sabha MP Dr. Subramanian Swamy has urged the central government to impose president's rule in the state. As the ruling party in the state has attacked the opposition, the center has a constitutional right to take action against the state. He pointed out that whatever TMC is doing is unconstitutional, and center can issue a warning to the state government under Article 256.

Is there enough evidence to link MPs in question with scams?

According to the information available in public domain, TMC's Lok Sabha MP Sudip Bandyopadhyay is a family friend of Gautam Kundu. He has also served as a director for one of the companies owned by the Rose Valley Group.

Even party’s Lok Sabha MP Tapas Pal has served as one of Rose Valley's board of directors along with his wife Nandini Paul.

Party's former Rajya Sabha MP Srinjoy Bose was arrested in connection with Saradha scam. Another Rajya Sabha MP from TMC-Kunal Ghosh had to spend three years behind bars in the same Saradha scam. TMC has suspended Ghosh, but he had opened a can of worms by claiming that several leaders from the party, including WB's CM are involved in the scam. These are just a few names out of the list that consists of leaders from multiple parties.

Currently, Saradha chit fund scam as well as Rose Valley chit fund scam are being investigated by the Enforcement Directorate and CBI. 

There are two points that need attention. First, there are several PILs in the HC and SC about these chit fund scams from West Bengal. CBI started the investigation during the UPA rule and arrested TMC MP. But that time, TMC did not blame Manmohan Singh or make any comments against the UPA for arresting its leaders.

Second is that in 2016, even state's Economic Offences Wing (EOW) and CID has arrested hundreds of people related to both scams. Thus, logically, West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee is not in a position to claim that this is a political vendetta against her party.

At this point, it won't be wrong to conclude that noise, hysteria and all the protests from TMC are to divert attention. Crime was committed, PILs were filed about the same, cases are being heard in various courts, leaders from TMC are not cooperating in investigations, and when they are arrested, the party is coming out to defend them.

"If you are not in crime, you won't be investigated. The question is not about why Trinamool Congress leaders are being investigated. The question is why they were involved in crime and looting people,” said BJP spokesperson Nalin Kohli, during The Newshour debate. This perfectly makes sense.

Should other pillars of democracy look into this issue?

This is nothing new; BJP workers often face attacks in West Bengal and Kerala. Recently released news story about how CPI (M) worker attacked BJP guy's car and threw his 10-month old baby out of the vehicle is still making headlines.

The SC has rightly banned candidates from using caste, religion to gain votes. But, the same democratic pillar has maintained silence on political violence in West Bengal. They have not issued any observation about WB's communal violence as well. Sometimes they make comments on issues even without PILs. 

Most debatable part is the role that Election Commission can play in stopping these incidents.

Pune-based Advocate Ramesh Rathore interacted with us and shared his opinion on this matter. He pointed out that as this is political violence, the EC should definitely consider looking into the issue. They can also consider revoking license of the parties that attack political opponents and act against the constitution.

Nitten Gokhaley

Nitten is a consultant journalist based in Pune and he writes on crime, politics, as well as business. 






  • Aditi Jain  
    political violence is bad
    • Faking News: Sasikala Will Open Jai Sasi Mata Ashrama

      VK Sasikala has decided to leave politics as she is ‘tired of the materialism of the material world’; she now wants to open an ashrama to teach people on how to react to the Read More

      BSNL and Nokia On A Same Platform For 5G Technology In India

      Government Sector Telecom Company Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (i.e. BSNL) and Nokia have come on a same platform to develop 5G ecosystems in the country. 5G technology helps to make broadband Read More

      Meat Shops in Gurgaon Closed By Shiv Sena for Navratri

      More than 300 meat shops have been allegedly shut down by force in Gurgaon, as Shiv Sena thinks open meat shops can pollute the purity of Navratri, a Hindu religious festival. An outlet of KFC, Read More

      Industries and States Face the Heat of Liquor Ban

      Supreme Court’s recent order of liquor ban around 500m of all national and state highways has cast havoc on the liquor industry, hospitality sector and state revenues. The restaurants, pubs Read More

      US Army around the world

      Senior Army and Pentagon strategists and organizers are thinking about ways to fire existing weapons platforms in new ways around the world - including the possible positioning of mobile artillery Read More

      A Number of Scam Centers are Fooling Foreign Customers

      A new wave of scam has blemished the image of India among foreign customers, who have been tricked by fake call centers to waste their hard earned money in fraudulent schemes. All of it came to Read More

      Now Auto permit for those who do not know Marathi in Maharashtra

      In Maharashtra, auto permits are given to those who do not speak Marathi language. The Bombay High Court on Wednesday declared the order issued by Devendra Fadnavis government last year as Read More

      Goods and Services Tax Comes into Application

      July 1, 2017 becomes a remarkable date in the history of Indian Economy. At midnight on June 30, the PM and his cabinet ministers along with the advisories will launch the GST at the Parliament. Read More

      Government initiates move to fix black spots on highways in 4 years

      The road transport and highways ministry has prepared a list of black spots on national highways to be fixed on priority basis to reduce the number of road deaths. India has the highest number of Read More

      Arrest Warrant Against Aravind Kejriwal

      Delhi chief minister Mr Aravind Kejriwal has made headlines again, for all wrong reasons. An Assam court told him to attend a session regarding a defamation case; after Kejriwal became absent in Read More