Why marital rape law can't be applied in India?

WHY MARITAL RAPE LAW CAN'T BE APPLIED IN INDIA?

Why marital rape law can't be applied in India?

Everything is in place for an Indian guy to rape his wife because Indian culture differs and Western notions of marital rape can't be applied to it. That, pretty much, is the essence of what Maneka Gandhi, India's Minister for females and Child Development, told MPs lately. Gandhi's remarks, indicative of the government's thinking on the problem, are the most recent contribution to a very long running debate in India as if the marital rape should be made a criminal offence. Laws on marital rape cannot be properly applied in the Indian context due to various factors like level of education/illiteracy, poverty, myriad social customs and values, religious beliefs, mindset of the society to treat the marriage as a sacrament etc. The minister said in a written response in the upper house of Parliament. 

Her answer triggered howls of protest, though she was trotting out a perspective that's popular in some circles of Indian society - that Indian culture is extraordinary and so must be measured differently from that of the West. This perspective postulates that Indian culture is superior to Western culture, that its worth are more powerful and that the institution of marriage is more sacrosanct. If Indian culture is exceptional in whatever manner, it is only in how it is terribly unkind to women, who must bow to man dominance and have little say about his life, from childhood to old age. 

Many committees and commissions have been set up through the years to advise governments on whether marital rape should be criminalized and most have argued against it, numerous reasons comparable to the ones given by Ms. Gandhi. Following the infamous 2012 Delhi gang rape the Justice Verma Commission was set up to look into violence against women. It  recommended that the law be amended to specify that a marital relationship isn't a valid defense against rape. It's precisely the patriarchy embedded in Indian culture that makes it imperative for wives to be protected against forced sex by their husbands. It's precisely the poverty and illiteracy that Ms. Gandhi cited that leave many girls vulnerable and in need of legal protection. Opponents of making marital rape a crime argue that marriages would be weakened by false allegations. Taking into consideration the reluctance with which Indian girls report rape by a stranger, it's unlikely that wives will be queuing up outside police stations to make false accusations against their husbands.




Name:

Email:

Contact

Comment:

Comments

    New President of India

    India is going to have its new president around the middle of this year, as Mr Pranab Mukherjee’s tenure ends at July 24. The NDA including BJP holds control over 47.5 % votes of the Read More


    India does not Want US to Mediate in Indo-Pak Tension

    India has refused the proposal of the United States, for mediating in the Indo-Pak tension. The US says that the Indo-Pak peace is a big concern for them and they would like to take part in the Read More


    Conundrum was made for the sum insured, the police also remained stunned

    In order to get the Insurance money in Surat, a man created such a ficious story, in which there were such revelations that police also remain stunned. The incident is in Mudat village of Surat, Read More


    Legal Cases in Delhi

    According to latest data evaluated on August 18 by the National Judicial Data Grid, 33,57,575 cases have been defined as 'unlisted'. Any case for which the next date of hearing has not Read More


    Delhi Rape

    The 2012 Delhi gang rape case included a rape and deadly assault that happened on 16 December 2012 in Munirka, a neighborhood in South Delhi. The event took place when Jyoti Singh, a 23 year old Read More


    Mumbai ATS Catches Suspected Terrorists

    Five people suspected to be connected with terror groups were nabbed in Mumbai after an excellent teamwork by the ATS of UP and Mumbai, Andhra Pradesh CI and Delhi Special Cell. Nazim Shamshad Read More


    Mission Swachh Bharat

    The Prime Minister Narendra Modi is working  hard for Mission Swachh Bharat. He said, "the mission should become the agenda of the entire country in the form of a mass movement Read More


    Dharamshala Stadium – Country’s most beautiful stadium is now set to create history

    Himachal Pradesh Cricket Association (HPCA) Stadium, situated at the height of 1317 meters from the sea level  in the lap of the Dauladhar hills will be recorded in chronicles on Saturday. In Read More


    Government Tough On Doctors in Maharashtra

    The Maharashtra Government has taken a tough stand against the doctors on strike; the ‘join work or lose salary’ stand of the Maharashtra Govt has been vehemently criticized by the Read More


    Are some cops denying the constitutional right to citizens by not registering FIR?

    Cops are public servants, hired to serve us, the sovereign people. Their job is to maintain law and order, offer safety, security and to detect, prevent as well as investigate the crime. They have Read More